

LA Galaxy 0-2 Seattle (Or: WOW! The Rules DO Apply to David Beckham!)
By: Laurie | August 16th, 2009
I am taking a longish blogging (slash son getting chemo) break. Truly I am. Except that I am just bubbling over with a need to talk about last night’s game, so I figure it’s best to just blog it all out and be done with it.
Must confess here that I was not able to watch the game as it was happening. Not that I was doing anything more important. Just that I could not take it if they’d played another game like last week. So I hit “record” and took the dog for a walk and timed it so I would not be back at the house until 10:01. Then I went immediately to MLSnet to find the score. And only then did I watch the game.
Okay, yeah, so this probably makes me a coward. But it’s been a rough week. Which somehow the win makes all (or almost all) better. Funny how that works, isn’t it?
About the game. First thing: I love James Riley. Meaning: I LOVE James Riley. Meaning, if he is ever orphaned, I am hereby offering to adopt him. (Because I ask you: Who would not want to be a part of my family?)
I’ve watched the Eddie Lewis red card sequence several times now, and here is my interpretation of the thoughts that must have run through James’ head:
Thought one: “Hey! That guy just elbowed me in the back of the head! Twice!”
Thought two: “Damn! That freakin’ hurt!”
Thought three: “I am not doing my team any favors by manning it out and staying on my feet here. OW!!! Can’t…walk! Legs…buckling!”
Pretty sure that every single boo afterwards just reinforced the wisdom of his choices.
Also: how…symmetrical was it that the red card came against the Galaxy? The only thing better would have been if it had been Gregg Berhalter rather than Eddie Lewis. I love James Riley.
(Wait, maybe I said that already.)
Also: The David Beckham red. Was anybody else shocked! SHOCKED!! to discover that MLS rules actually apply to David Beckham? I thought there was a special double-super-secret set of David Beckham rules, which started out with “The Beckham shall NEVER receive a red card.”
Apparently I was wrong. Thank you, jeebus. (And thank you, Ricardo Salazar.)
What’s funny is that in Becks’ post-game presser he protested his innocence, saying that he didn’t deserve the red because this was in no way malicious. Which is kind of funny, because if he’d been paying attention at all to MLS (which he obviously has not, being far too busy with AC Milan and England to spare a thought for our little bush league that’s paying him $6.5m a year), he would know that malicious intent is not a factor in awarding red cards. It’s a bit more about punishing recklessness that could break legs.
Or, in other words: Sucks to be you this week, David.
The best part about this is that Beckham and Lewis will now be missing for their midweek game against Chicago, which we really need LA to lose to help us in our quest for a playoff spot. Not that I’m in any way feeling an emotion as base as schadenfreude. Or anything.
A few more random thoughts:
- Who was that masked man, and what did he do with Pete Vagenas?
- Steve Zakuani was a beast! This is the Stevie Z that everybody has hoped was lurking behind the switch-it-to-the-right-foot-and-hesitate-long-enough-to-give-up-the-ball guy we saw too often earlier in the season. I would like nothing more than to see this guy be a huge enough success to make Arsenal regret giving him up. Go Steve!!
- Tyrone Marshall’s second yellow. Oy. I’m still hoping for a replay angle that will help me decide once and for all whether this was a Donovan dive or Marshall stupidity. Or both. Right now the jury is still out.
- Is anybody else wishing MLSnet had an “Assist of the Week” award? Because Brad Evans’ work on that first goal would be a shoo-in. (And how great was it that it was Berhalter who got smoked?)
- First win on grass. Second win away. Breaking long streaks for no goals and no away goals. In short, not a bad evening.
- I love Kasey Keller.
- One of the best things about this win is that it means we win the series with LA. Which means that — since the first tiebreak is head-to-head — if we tie with them at the end of the season, we’re the ones who move on. Which feels all kinds of good.
- I am really worried about Freddie Ljungberg. Disorientation and memory loss not related to migraines? That is scary. Let’s hope it’s just a new migraine symptom and not a sign of some kind of neurological event. Looking on the positive, though, it is nice to realize we can do this without him.
Okay, I’m done now. Crawling back into my isolationist hole.
(Photo: Victor Decolongon / Getty Images / August 15, 2009)
![]() |
MLS Forums | MLS Results |
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments | Add your comment
-



Yeah, Freddie’s symptoms do sound very scary. Although I have to say that if you’re going to get some horrible disease, Seattle is one of the best places in the world to be. Hopefully it’s nothing serious, though.
Posted from
United States

-



This is my first visit to the Sounders blog. Great write up. You actually made me want to watch a MLS game. As a childhood cancer survivor, I wish you & your son the best of luck. And I can’t help but put the name “St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital” out there for you to Google.
Posted from
United States

-



Just a note, Laurie. The Beckham foul was a legitimate booking. Probably yellow more than red, but he risked it with the studs up (even though replays show he barely clipped the edge of Pete’s shoe and Pete worked it like an Oscar nominee). As for you love affair with Riley, his drama is what I hate about Spanish and Italian leagues. Gamesmanship is deplorable, even if its your home team. Landon Donavan does it for LA too and it caught the Sounders just before lewis got shown off. All of it is a genuine lack of sportsmanship. The Sunday football recap on BBC summed it up. They felt that the MLS will never get any respect until the refs learn to call a game properly and don’t fall for the gamesmanship. Chivas-LA earlier this year was another example. Don’t support the problem by putting Riley on a pedastal. He deserved a card more then Lewis did.
Posted from
United States

-



Erik, I don’t know anybody who’d disagree with you on the MLS refereeing. It sucks. The sooner they do something about it, the better.
But the funny/great thing about the Lewis red from the point of view of Sounders fans was that it should DEFINITELY have been a red, regardless of Riley’s response. US Soccer has repeatedly informed the referees this season that intentional contact above the shoulders is ALWAYS a red card, no matter what. This has bitten the Sounders several times this season — Montero (against Chicago), Marshall (I think, against Columbus) and yes, James Riley. Against the Galaxy, no less.
In the Mother’s Day game, Mike Magee grabbed Riley by the back of the neck. Riley grabbed back. Magee went down like he’d been shot, and Riley saw red. Magee got nothing, except if I remember correctly a yellow for dissent or something basically unrelated.
For Eddie Lewis to do something as goofy as smacking Riley in the back of the head not once but twice, resulting in red, was a) really stupid and b) too funny for words, from a karma kind of standpoint.
I don’t like the playacting and embellishment any more than you do, but Seattle has been punished for not doing it, as evidenced by their standing at the bottom of the Fair Play table despite their suffering among the most fouls against in the league. I don’t condone outright diving, ever, but when a legitimate foul is committed, we’re not doing ourselves any favors by staying upright and not drawing attention to it. And that’s the truth.
Posted from
United States

-



ScudettoStarved,
All is going well and the kind words are much appreciated. Thank you.
Posted from
United States

-



“US Soccer has repeatedly informed the referees this season that intentional contact above the shoulders is ALWAYS a red card, no matter what.”
That’s not precisely the interpretation, but it’s more or less accurate. Give me about 75 pages, and I can clear it up for you, I’m sure you’ll be intrigued
Posted from
United States

-



As I was typing that part of the comment, I was actually thinking, “Dustin is going to stop by and take issue with that blanket statement.”
Posted from
United States

-



I just went back and watched the Marshall second yellow and the Lewis red. The easy one, and this is not just me being a homer: based on the standards US Soccer has set this season, the Lewis red was 100% accurate. He smacked Riley with the left hand on the back of the head first, then turned around and backhanded him with his right, out of bounds and after the whistle had blown. The original video and first replay block what happened, but the final replay on MLSnet shows it clearly. That’s a red.
The Marshall second yellow, not so much. Marshall’s foot was planted before Donovan got there, and Donovan dramatically tripped over it. But there did seem like there might have been a bit of hip check in there too? Dustin, what’s your interpretation?
Posted from
United States

-



It looked to me that Marshall step forward right before Donovan got there, closing the gap between them and giving Donovan less room to push the ball around and run past. A bit of a hip check I guess, but it wasn’t much. The reason I think is because Marshall had been warned over and over by Salazar about his physical play. Also where the foul happened in the attacking third with the opposing teams playmaker going towards goal, highly questionable whether or not it was an accident.
I can see WHY Salazar would give a yellow card given all those things. I wouldn’t necessarily point to this video as the way referees should do things. I’d point to it in order to bring up what you should think about when looking at plays of this sort.
Lots of people are saving Donovan dove. I think he made a meal of it, but he was also closed down, so it’s anyones guess what he was thinking during that.
Posted from
United States

Leave a Reply
If you have not commented here before, please take a moment to peruse ourCommenting Guidelines.













